7 practical tips for navigating the hardest conversations in financial planning

Helping clients through life’s toughest financial conversations

Meet Renee, who is raising four children while helping her parents, both in their late 80s, remain at home. Her father’s diabetic neuropathy makes driving and giving himself insulin more difficult. Her mother is less steady on her feet and seems more forgetful. Renee’s regular check-ins have become doctor’s appointments, time away from work to help after her mother’s knee replacement and more frequent visits. Her parents are frustrated that everyday tasks are getting harder, and Renee worries about their safety.

Life can change in seconds at any age. For “sandwiched” adults, a parent’s fall or a minor car accident can bring a wave of questions that the family has not discussed:

• What if Mom falls going down the stairs in her house?
• What does Dad want if he needs more intensive care?

Many people with aging parents will face similar situations. Conversations about caregiving and end-of-life wishes can feel uncomfortable, but talking as a family sooner can bring clarity and lower anxiety.

Why caregiving conversations can be challenging

Emotions can run high. When caregiving conversations are on the horizon, adult children may feel overwhelmed, guilty or sad. Discussing changes in a parent’s health, care needs beyond what their children can provide or end-of-life decisions can be difficult for everyone. Avoiding these conversations may leave a family unprepared as a parent’s needs change.

“Caregiving conversations are often avoided because they touch much deeper emotions:  autonomy, identity, fear of becoming a burden and mortality.”

These conversations can be just as hard for parents. “The ones who deflect caregiving conversations aren't necessarily in denial about their health or age,” according to Lutter. “More often, they're protecting their sense of self.”

Being told it is time to hand over the car keys or that you “can’t take care of yourself anymore” can feel less like concern and more like losing independence. Lutter suggests framing caregiving conversations around what aging parents stand to keep, rather than focusing too much on what is changing.

“Language matters enormously here. Reframing the issue helps preserve a parent’s autonomy while still naming the need.”

Word choice and tone can make or break progress

Suppose Renee notices her mother having more trouble keeping up with the house. Saying, “You don't seem able to keep up lately. Maybe the house is getting to be too much for you,” could sound like an accusation and cause her mother to shut down.

Renee could try a more empathetic approach: “I know how much you love being in this house. Having someone come in to help out can go a long way toward helping you stay here.” By framing her concern around a positive outcome, the conversation may have a better chance of moving forward.

Adult children may come from a place of concern, while parents may feel their children are trying to parent them. When defenses go up, positive outcomes can depend less on what is said than on how it is said. Conversations that feel overly parental can lead to frustration or resentment and derail the goal of caring for parents in a loving, respectful way where everyone feels heard.

The financial professional’s expanding role

Caregiving conversations are among the hardest financial professionals face. Talking about caring for a loved one or making end-of-life decisions can overwhelm even emotionally stable people. Financial professionals do not need to be therapists or have all the answers; they need to be willing to listen, advises Lutter.

“Financial professionals can bring a lot of value to difficult family conversations by making it safe and structured enough for clients and their families to have the conversations themselves.”

When conversations go well, the value is more than a completed care plan. Families who can talk about caregiving early, while stress is manageable, may avoid making decisions in a hospital hallway during a crisis. They are also more likely to have a plan everyone feels comfortable with.

7 ways to help guide caregiving conversations

Here are seven ideas Lutter suggests for guiding clients through emotionally charged conversations:

1. Open the door without forcing the topic

Simple, low-pressure language works best. Make an observation or ask a question, such as:

• “It sounds like there's a lot happening in your family right now.”
• “Would you like to initiate that conversation with your siblings, or could I help facilitate a call?”

Both examples signal availability without pushing a client somewhere they are not ready to go.

2. Reassure the client and parent

Adult children need to hear that wanting help for a parent is a responsible, loving choice, not a betrayal. A simple reassurance can help move a stuck conversation forward:

“This is hard for both of you, and it's normal to feel that way. But everyone at this table wants the same thing: for your mom to be safe and for your family to stay close, not grow apart.”

3. Ask how, not just what

A question such as “Tell me how you came to this decision” may surface the reasoning and family dynamics behind a choice, not just the choice itself. It can also uncover which relationships are driving resistance.

4. Notice what isn't being said

If a client looks at their partner every time a certain topic comes up, gently name what you notice. For example: “I notice you look at your partner when we discuss this. I'm curious why.” Curiosity, not confrontation, tends to open the door further.

5. Reset the conversation when emotions rise

Managing family dynamics can take practice. When siblings disagree or a caregiving conversation repeatedly breaks down, try resetting the discussion. More thoughtful decision-making can continue when tempers cool. Acknowledge family members who want to speak and help create a discussion where everyone has a chance to share their views.

6. Turn “what if” into a plan

Address costs and legal logistics directly to help relieve stress rather than add to it. A family with a plan, instead of a list of “what ifs,” may be better able to shift its focus from money worries to the care a loved one needs.

This is also a time to watch for financial exploitation. Warning signs can include unpaid bills, unexplained account activity, a new person exercising unusual influence, or abrupt changes to a will or beneficiaries. These signs may surface before a family realizes a loved one needs additional support.

7. Know your own patterns

Financial professionals bring their own money scripts and family histories into the room. If a client’s anxiety triggers your own, the client may notice. Stay present and remain objective.

Connect caregiving decisions to retirement planning

A productive caregiving conversation can uncover planning gaps before a crisis forces a family to act. This is especially important for “sandwiched” clients supporting aging parents while preparing for their own retirement. Caring for or helping support parents could affect how much adult children can save, when they retire and how reliably their assets need to produce income.

By helping families discuss decisions early and connecting care choices to a client’s retirement plan, financial professionals can provide value beyond portfolio recommendations. You can help bring families together by making tough caregiving conversations safe and structured. When emotions are calm, you can also help caregiving clients consider whether strategies such as protected income could support their retirement plan.

For “sandwiched” clients caring for multiple generations while trying to save for retirement, help keep their own future financial security a priority. Explore how annuities could support their retirement plans  

Insights on Athene Connect. Tips, tools and resources to help grow your business by helping clients retire with confidence.